Canadian Publishers Clear Key Hurdle as Ontario Court Keeps OpenAI Copyright Lawsuit in Canada

Ontario's Court of Appeal has dismissed OpenAI's appeal, allowing Canada's largest news publishers to press ahead with their copyright lawsuit over the use of their journalism to train ChatGPT. The ruling decides only where the case is heard — no court has yet ruled on whether OpenAI infringed copyright.

Nov 15, 2026 - 19:09
 0  6
Canadian Publishers Clear Key Hurdle as Ontario Court Keeps OpenAI Copyright Lawsuit in Canada
The stone facade of Osgoode Hall in Toronto, home of the Ontario Court of Appeal, with tall columns, arched windows and a cobblestone courtyard framed by trees on a sunny day.

Canadian Publishers Clear Key Hurdle as Ontario Court Keeps OpenAI Copyright Lawsuit in Canada

Canada's largest news publishers can press ahead with their copyright lawsuit against OpenAI in Ontario, after the province's Court of Appeal dismissed the company's attempt to move the case to the United States. The ruling, released on Friday, November 13, 2026, is a significant early win for the publishers — but it settles only where the case will be heard, not whether OpenAI did anything wrong.

The lawsuit is the first Canadian case to address whether using copyrighted journalism to train generative AI systems breaches copyright law. A unanimous three-judge panel, led by Justice B.W. Miller, found that Ontario has a "real and substantial connection" to the alleged breaches, and ordered OpenAI to pay $100,000 in legal costs to the publisher group.

What the court decided

OpenAI, the California-based company behind ChatGPT, had challenged the Ontario courts' jurisdiction over the case. It argued that the alleged infringements happened outside Canada, fell beyond the reach of Canadian copyright law, and belonged in a United States courtroom. The Court of Appeal rejected that argument in full, upholding a November 2025 ruling by Justice Jessica Kimmel of the Ontario Superior Court of Justice. The appellate decision is cited as 2026 ONCA 814.

The court also noted that OpenAI filed no evidence showing that a judgment in Canada would conflict with any existing United States laws in a way that would complicate enforcement. And it endorsed the lower court's view that "the fair and efficient working of the Canadian legal system favoured allowing Canadian authors to bring claims against foreign companies for breaches of Canadian laws."

The earlier ruling had applied the "real and substantial connection" test, finding a good arguable case linking OpenAI's operating entities to Ontario through business activity, alleged local acts and website terms. The appeal court also weighed Ontario customers, contracts and Canadian servers in reaching its conclusion.

The lawsuit so far

The action was filed in Toronto on November 28, 2024, by Toronto Star Newspapers Limited, Metroland Media Group, Postmedia Network, PNI Maritimes, The Globe and Mail, The Canadian Press and CBC/Radio-Canada. The publishers allege that OpenAI collected and reproduced large quantities of their journalistic work without permission, used it in datasets to train the GPT models behind ChatGPT, and profited from the resulting systems.

Their claims include breaches of the Copyright Act, breach of contract through the publishers' website terms of use, and unjust enrichment. All of those allegations remain unproven, and no court has yet ruled on whether OpenAI infringed copyright.

With the appeal dismissed, the case now returns to the Ontario Superior Court, where it will move toward a hearing on the merits — the stage at which the court will consider whether OpenAI's use of the publishers' work actually breached Canadian copyright law. No hearing date has been set.

Why this case matters beyond Canada

The decision puts Canada on the map in a fast-growing global legal fight over AI training data. In the United States, multiple lawsuits dealing with AI systems and copyright are already underway, some dating back to 2023 — including a case by publishers including the Toronto Star, Condé Nast and McClatchy alleging that Canadian AI company Cohere infringed their copyright by scraping their articles from the internet without permission or compensation.

Earlier this year, Postmedia, Torstar, The Globe and Mail and The Canadian Press launched a separate lawsuit against AI company Anthropic, another major developer of large language models.

News and cultural industry groups have called on the federal government to take a stand on how AI systems use copyrighted content, but Ottawa has not indicated any plans to do so or to update the Copyright Act. For now, the courts are where the rules are being tested — and with Friday's ruling, the Canadian test case will be argued in Ontario.

Sources

  • The Canadian Press, "Court allows news publishers' copyright lawsuit against OpenAI to go ahead," November 13, 2026 (via Winnipeg Free Press / EuropeSays)
  • Broadcast Dialogue, "Ontario court rejects OpenAI appeal in Canadian media lawsuit," November 13, 2026
  • The Apex Wire, "Ontario Court Lets Publishers Sue OpenAI Over AI Training Copyright," November 2026
  • Bars Across, "Ontario Court of Appeal Keeps OpenAI Copyright Case in Canada," November 2026

What's Your Reaction?

Like Like 0
Dislike Dislike 0
Love Love 0
Funny Funny 0
Angry Angry 0
Sad Sad 0
Wow Wow 0
Nahid Joy I’m Nahid Hasan Joy, a technology writer, web developer, and digital enthusiast with a strong interest in the ever-changing world of technology.