Newsmax Sues Fox to Unwind $22 Billion Roku Deal Over Free Streaming Dominance
Newsmax has filed a federal antitrust lawsuit seeking to unwind Fox's $22 billion acquisition of Roku, arguing the combined company would control more than 70 percent of the free ad-supported streaming TV market in the United States.
Newsmax Sues Fox to Unwind $22 Billion Roku Deal Over Free Streaming Dominance
Newsmax has sued Fox in federal court to block and unwind its $22 billion takeover of Roku, arguing that the completed deal hands one company too much power over free, ad-supported streaming television in the United States.
The lawsuit, filed on Wednesday, November 18, in the U.S. District Court for the Northern District of California, comes less than two weeks after Fox announced it had completed the acquisition on November 6 — months earlier than the companies had publicly projected. It is a rare attempt to undo a deal that antitrust regulators have already allowed to close.
What the lawsuit asks for
Newsmax is asking a judge to halt further integration of Fox and Roku, to issue a preliminary injunction, and to order Roku to keep operating independently while the case proceeds. The complaint also asks the court to unwind the deal entirely unless Fox sells either Tubi, its free streaming service, or The Roku Channel.
The complaint accuses Fox and Roku of violating the Clayton Act, the federal law that prohibits acquisitions whose effect may be to substantially lessen competition or tend to create a monopoly. Newsmax argues that the merger should be stopped — or broken up — before the two businesses are woven together in ways that cannot easily be undone.
The 70 percent claim at the heart of the case
The central allegation is about scale. Newsmax contends that Tubi and The Roku Channel together account for more than 70 percent of viewing time in the U.S. market for free, ad-supported streaming television — the segment of the industry known as FAST, where viewers watch programming for free in exchange for seeing advertisements.
According to the complaint, Nielsen data puts The Roku Channel at roughly 42 percent of that market and Tubi at more than 28 percent. That is Newsmax's allegation, not a finding by a court, and the figure is likely to become a central point of dispute: antitrust cases often turn on how the relevant market is defined and whether the company accused actually holds the power attributed to it.
Fox owns Tubi and now owns Roku, which makes streaming devices, runs a connected-television platform and operates The Roku Channel. Roku's platform and Fox's programming now sit inside the same company, Fox Digital Platforms, alongside Tubi, Fox One and Fox's other digital businesses.
Why Newsmax says it is harmed
Newsmax says the deal threatens its own business directly. The company operates Newsmax TV and the free streaming channel Newsmax2, and it says it relies on The Roku Channel for distribution. It also says Fox had previously refused to carry Newsmax on Tubi — a refusal it points to as evidence of how the combined company could disadvantage competing content providers.
The complaint argues that combining the platforms eliminates competition for viewers and programming rights, and gives Fox greater influence over how rival services appear on Roku devices, including in search results.
Newsmax also challenges the assurances Fox gave regulators. The Justice Department's Antitrust Division closed its review of the deal on November 6, the day it closed, concluding the acquisition was not likely to harm competition. Fox made commitments in connection with that review, including pledges not to discriminate against non-Fox content in search results and to keep Roku an open and neutral platform. Newsmax argues those pledges are unenforceable because they were not set out in a consent decree or a court order.
Fox rejects the claims
Fox has rejected the lawsuit. A company spokesperson said the complaint is wholly without merit and has no basis in fact, pointing to the rigorous review the transaction went through with regulatory agencies before it was approved. Fox said it has begun integrating the approved transaction for the benefit of consumers, partners and other stakeholders.
Roku and Fox did not immediately respond to Reuters' requests for comment when the lawsuit was first reported. Bloomberg first reported the filing.
What happens next
The case now turns on whether a judge grants Newsmax's request for a preliminary injunction and a hold-separate order. If the court refuses, Fox can keep integrating Roku while the case moves forward — and the longer the two companies operate as one, the harder an unwind becomes. If the court intervenes, the deal that regulators cleared in November could face a long and uncertain fight in court.
For the wider streaming industry, the case is a test of whether private antitrust lawsuits can still challenge a completed deal after the Justice Department has decided not to. The outcome will be watched closely by every free streaming service that depends on Roku's platform to reach viewers.
Sources
- Reuters — Newsmax sues Fox to unwind $22 billion Roku takeover
- The Desk — Newsmax sues to unwind Roku acquisition by Fox
- Barrett Media — Newsmax Sues FOX, Roku to Block $22 Billion Acquisition
- Cord Cutters News — Newsmax Files Antitrust Lawsuit Against Fox's Completed Roku Acquisition
- PYMNTS — Newsmax Sues to Block Fox-Roku Integration After $22 Billion Deal
What's Your Reaction?
Like
0
Dislike
0
Love
0
Funny
0
Angry
0
Sad
0
Wow
0